Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Wages

On a free market*, the wage level will always be what the market decides. No union in the world can raise wages above the market level, and no employer in the world can pay less than it. The reason for this is that an employer that pays less, will not get employees enough, and an employer who pays more, will run out of business.

Wages cause heated discussions, and the reason for this is that most people are either wage-earners (like me) or wage-payers (like my employer). Wages are crucial to both wage-earners, who live by them, and wage-payers, who obviously pays them.

Most people fail, or refuse, to understand that the price of labor is just like the price of any other good or service bought and sold on the market, at least in a strictly economical point of view. Wages do not pop out of the sky** but depend on the price of the goods or services produced, and that price can only be set either voluntarily, by the market, or through force, by governmnent.

Do I need to remind my readers that the wages in the private, or semi-private, sector in general are higher than the wages in the public sector, in every country that I know of?

*Which is not what any country has today, although some countries, e.g. Singapore, get pretty close.
**Although many seem to believe that.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, December 06, 2006

Free to choose

I have recently watched the late Milton Friedman's classical TV series "Free to choose". I enjoyed it. Friedman discusses basic but important subjects. Although there were no real news for me there, I consider Friedman a good teacher, and he gives convincing examples of his theories in action, in the US, Hong Kong, Japan, the UK, and eastern Europe. He shows the importance of incentives, and what happens when they are allowed to work through a free market, and also what happens when they are not allowed to work, because of government regulations of the market. One point I really liked was that the so-called third way, between capitalism and socialism, could only work (i.e. not lead to misery in the short run) in countries that had first experienced laissez-faire or almost laissez-faire capitalism, and he gives us the examples of the UK and Sweden. No country has ever been able to go from state socialism (central planning) to the third way. Being a Swede, I second that opinion.

I strongly recommend "Free to choose". Not only did I enjoy the shows, I also enjoyed the introductions by Arnold Schwarzenegger, Ronald Reagan, Steve Allen and David Friedman, and I enjoyed the discussions where Milton Friedman discussed with those who agreed with him, e.g. Gary Becker and Thomas Sowell, and with those who did not agree with him, e.g. James Gailbraith.

Watch it!

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, November 28, 2006

Institutionalised force

I define a state as an organization which claims a monopoly of the use of force, of legislation, of inner and outer defense (police and military), and of taxation, over a given territorial area. The usual defense for the state, as opposed to anarchy, goes something like this: "Without a state, there will be chaos. Society will fall apart, and biker gangs and other criminals will be the new rulers".

Let's stick to the facts. Government, in its better forms, is what you have in countries like Denmark and New Zeeland. In its worse forms, government is what you have in countries like the Soviet Union and Pol Pot's Cambodia. Anarchy, i.e. stateless society, has succesfully been practised in Iceland and the American West, and less succesfully in Somalia (which I still find preferrable over Cambodia).

Actually, I sincerely believe that the state increases the amount of force in society. The reason for this is that government and its institutions provides a power structure for power freaks and others with attitude problems. I doubt that my readers are surpriced by my claim that many police and military officers are aggressive and violent, and that many bureaucrats are rud. I believe this aggression, violence and rudeness from government is made easier (for government) by the lack of competition in those areas which have been monopolized by government.

The reason for this is that government can externalise its costs to the tax-payers. The tax-payers do not pay taxes voluntarily. They pay because government forces them to do so. In a stateless society, it is reasonable to suppose that protection will be offered by private defense agencier (PDAs). I cannot predict human action in detail, since human action to an extent is unpredictable. It is not, however, completely unpredictable. Conscious beings, e.g. humen, respond to incentives, and since firms (such as PDAs) are run by humen, firms too respond to incentives.

A PDA cannot externalise its costs the same way as a government does, because the PDA's revenues are paid by customers. A PDA cannot force its customers to hire them. A PDA which engages in harassments of innocent people or warfare will have to charge its customers more. I do not believe that most people are willing to pay more without getting something in return, and thus a PDA which involves itself in destructive action (i.e. harassment and/or warfare) will be out-competed by PDAs which stays out of that.

It should also not be forgotten that governments can be corrupted, much easier than a PDA is corrupted. It is a fact that both local and national governments are corrupted, and there are examples of this in my hometown of Oslo, Norway, as well as of mafia influence of (previous?) Italian governments and the Enron scandal in the US. The incentives for governments not to be corrupted are non-existent or small, since the tax-payers are not allowed to stop paying taxes or to withhold taxes from government.

In the case of a PDA, the situation is different, because a PDA operates on a free market. If a PDA is corrupted, it will lose customers. When it loses customers, it loses revenues, and it will then be less attractive to investors as well as to "corruptors". These facts point to a simple conclusion: a stateless society, where defense is provided by PDAs, will not be a corrupted, violent and chaotic society, but a peaceful and prosperous one.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, November 25, 2006

Two kinds of capitalism

There are two different kinds, or definitions, of capitalism.

1. Capitalism as a system of government-granted privileges. Many of the 19th century critics of capitalism opposed this capitalism.

2. Capitalism as a system of free enterprise and competition, with no government regulation of the market. Many of the 20th century defenders of capitalism defended this capitalism.

I totally oppose the first kind of capitalism. I am totally in favor of the second kind of capitalism.

Labels: , , , , ,

Monday, November 20, 2006

Quote of the day

"It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard for their own interests."
Adam Smith


More quotes.

Labels: , ,

Monday, October 30, 2006

The failure of the continental European model: France and Germany

I am reading "Muligheter for alle. Dynamisk vekst i en liberal markedsøkonomi" ("Opportunities for all. Dynamic growth in a liberal market economy") by Lars Peder Nordbakken. In the book, he mentions three different economic models: the Nordic model, the continental European model, and the Anglo-Saxon model.

The Nordic model is practiced in Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, and it combines an inclusive publicly financed welfare system and a large degree of social security with a liberal view on competition and markets, and a somewhat flexible labor market.

The Anglo-Saxon model is practiced in USA, Canada, Australia, UK and Ireland, and it combines a limited social security net with a liberal view on competition and markets, and a very flexible labor market.

The continental European model is practiced in France, Italy, Spain and Germany, and it combines a somewhat high social welfare system with an interventionist-protectionist view on competition and markets, and an over-regulated and unflexible labor market.

These definitions are according to Nordbakken, page 261 of the Norwegian-language edition.

One year ago, France was in flames. Unemployed minority youth were rioting. It is now feared that this will happen again soon. I am not defending riots, but I think that it is a pretty obvious result of the French society.

The news I've been reading lately have been reporting about the new under class of Germany, which is said to be about 8% of the German population. Unemployed and poor people, with no hope for the future. Germany, which used to be the "Wirtschaftswunder" (entrepreneurial wonder) turned into an over-regulated society, and these are the results.

Regulations are worst for poor people. Regulations are often said to help poor people, but they do not. Regulations hit poor people. People who want to work, but cannot find work, and who eventually gave up.

Germany and France are clear examples of the fact that the continental European model is a failure. It's creating large problems, ethnic and social tensions, and an unsocial society.

This model needs to be abolished, badly. I do not know whether France will be in flames again this year, but I am pretty sure both France and Germany will be in flames again, eventually.

This is an example of how "the road to hell is paved with good intentions". The social security nets and the regulations to make it harder to fire people, and (at least in the German case) subsidies for building plants in areas with high unemployment, were not imposed by politicians who wanted to hurt people, but by politicians who wanted to help people, who wanted to give them security.

The problem is, you cannot have security through coercion. When you make it expensive to hire people, and difficult to fire those already employed, the effect is an excluding labor market. Those without jobs are having difficulties finding any. Those with jobs seems to be privileged, but this system makes them less secure than on an unregulated labor market, since the heavy burdens on enterprise will make businesses move to less regulated areas. Businesses move, and few new businesses are started. The jobs are leaving, with no new jobs coming.

There are some things I believe to be fundamentally true. One of these things is that you cannot have consumption without production. When production goes down, consumption will have to go down too.

Not only businesses leave, but people do, too. Engineers are leaving Germany for the USA. Skilled workers move to the UK, Denmark, Austria and Norway.

A British politician said, last year, when a French politician criticized the Anglo-Saxon model: "If your social system is so great, why is your country in flames?".

I second that opinion. De-regulate the economy, now, for the sake of the poor! Give them chances!

Labels: , ,

Friday, October 20, 2006

Libertarianism=Anarchism

Which are the libertarian principles? The word libertarianism comes from the the English word liberty. Principled libertarianism is usually based on the Lockean trinity of rights: the right to life, liberty and property, and many libertarians also refer to the non-aggression principle (NAP), which means that you are not allowed to initiate use of force against others. You are, however, according to the NAP, allowed to use force to defend yourself and others, and in case of restitution.

Which are the anarchist principles? The word anarchism comes from the ancient Greek words an arkos, which means "no ruler". From what I understand, the basic anarchist principles are that no force and no fraud should be allowed.

Both libertarian and anarchist principles leads to the same conclusion: the right of individuals to make agreements, based on their own free will.

The effects of this simple conclusion are not easily understood, neither by those who call themselves anarchist, nor by those who call themselves libertarians. Many anarchists fail to understand that the right to make agreements means that there will capitalistic forms of production in an anarchy, i.e. firms, bosses and employees. At the same time, many libertarians fail to see that said right means that the state is an illegal institution that must be abolished, and that without state regulations of the market, there would be more competition from small firms against bigger corporations, more competition for labor, and that that in turn would drive wages up.

The way I see it, libertarians must be anarchists, and anarchists must be libertarians.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, October 18, 2006

The market must cater to minorities

Ramadan started on 23 September this year, and it ends
23 October. Most ethnic Swedes care little about this,
me included, because it is none of my business.

However, according to the Swedish newspaper Dagens
Nyheter,
Ramadan is a feast for Swedish grocery
chains. The article quotes representatives for Axfood
and Coop, two of the largest grocery chains in Sweden.

The persons quoted, Irene Seideman of Axfood and
Magnus Frisk of Coop, both have names that imply that
they are ethnic Swedes. It is not such a wild guess
that they do not celebrate Ramadan.

But as a business, operating on a market, a grocery
chain cannot afford not to cater to Muslims, at least
not when Muslims represent large numbers (although
still a minority) in Sweden. For the same reason that
grocery stores in areas in Sweden with many Finnish
immgrants sell the Finnish Lauantai makkara ("Saturday
sausage", which I recommend), they now sell beef
soup, chicken soup, dadles and baklava. The reason is
simple: there is a demand for it.

From my own experience, I know that you can buy halal
food in food stores in Oslo (a city with a large
Muslim minority), and eat Swedish-style pizza at a
restaurant in this city, because of the Swedish
minority here, creating a demand for it.

As opposed to politics, where a majority can oppress a
minority, in the market, that is too expensive.
Business cannot afford no to cater to minorities,
whether they are Swedes, Finns or Muslims.

Labels: , , , , , ,

The mentality to trade

There is one thing, that almost every human being has, and that will not be stopped. I am talking about the trading mentality.

Even hard-core-communists are still willing to make trades with you. In every socialist society (and to an extent, I would like to call all western societies socialist [of the 20th century definition of the word, state socialism]) there are black markets. In the Soviet Union, there were huge black markets.

But also in countries that are considered capitalist, there are black markets. Whenever something is taxed (at least if it's taxed high enough), there will be people willing to sell the good or service "under the table", for a lower price. Smuggling, working under the table, etc, are all effects of taxation and regulation.

There is no way to stop the trading mentality. (And it should not be stopped.)

Labels: , , ,